Having just purchased The Vanishing of Ethan Carter, I looked at the Steam page and found there were 14 hidden achievements. Initially, that seemed really unfair. How was I supposed to reach an achievement if I didn’t know what it was? That’s like playing darts with the lights off and not knowing where the dartboard is.
But then I looked at the Bioshock 2 page and found all the achievements listed and that seemed almost as bad. if I am just going to play a game to reach the achievements, won’t that take away some of the spontaneity of the experience?
So what is the middle ground? I don’t know, but perhaps it is that the achievements are hidden until after the first playthrough. Any achievements gained on the first playthrough are “Gold” or something, although people will just look for them online simply to get the gold star I suppose.
In fact, maybe make it so that it is impossible to get ANY achievements on the first playthrough!
Maybe there could be hints with the second and subsequent playthroughs to help you find the ones you missed.
How do you feel about the display or not of achievements?
Would you prefer achievements to be hidden until after the first playthrough of a game?
- Maybe, I'll comment to explain. (17%, 10 Votes)
- No, I want to know what they are from the beginning (22%, 13 Votes)
- Yes, it's better to play the game without worrying about them (62%, 37 Votes)
Total Voters: 60